• 0 Posts
  • 3 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle

  • I have to answer to this post directly… First of all: I am a member of the European free software foundation. I am since over 10 years.

    Using those distributions is, sadly, a security risk!

    Everybody must be absolutely clear about the fact that CPU microcode updates are property blobs, and therefore removed by those projects.

    This means: Your CPU runs with only the build in firmware and is most likely vulnerable against many CPU level attacks. CPU bugs can only be fixed with microcode , and if you drop those from the systems you leave the systems vulnerable.

    Full free software distributions are a important, but very esoteric.

    OP claims even the kernel itself is non free software. So let me just cite the kernel archive

    Is Linux Kernel Free Software?

    Linux kernel is released under the terms of GNU GPL version 2 and is therefore Free Software as defined by the Free Software Foundation.

    I heard that Linux ships with non-free “blobs”

    Before many devices are able to communicate with the OS, they must first be initialized with the “firmware” provided by the device manufacturer. This firmware is not part of Linux and isn’t “executed” by the kernel – it is merely uploaded to the device during the driver initialization stage.

    While some firmware images are built from free software, a large subset of it is only available for redistribution in binary-only form. To avoid any licensing confusion, firmware blobs were moved from the main Linux tree into a separate repository called linux-firmware.

    It is possible to use Linux without any non-free firmware binaries, but usually at the cost of rendering a lot of hardware inoperable. Furthermore, many devices that do not require a firmware blob during driver initialization simply already come with non-free firmware preinstalled on them. If your goal is to run a 100% free-as-in-freedom setup, you will often need to go a lot further than just avoiding loadable binary-only firmware blobs.

    https://www.kernel.org/faq.html


  • What a bunch of bullshit.

    Linux, first of all, is the kernel. Linux is GPL and always free.

    And userspace zurück itself is about 90% free.

    Of course, you can choose a 100% free os, then make sure you use a free bios and only open hardware CPU and Mainboard and memory! 09 This argument is esoteric. I am an FSF member, but I use Steam on Gentoo.

    The idea behind such distro lists is to show how hard it still is to provide a really 100% open source distro.

    Let me remind you, what is non free in in most systems:

    • CPU microcode!
    • GPU Firmware
    • Wifi / BT / Ethernet firmware
    • Media Codecs

    Stuff most users need!

    And what the fuck is I distro locking me in? I can switch my distro between boots without fucking loosing any data or configs, I can choose what to install. I can install stuff from source. How can you even try to compare this with Microsofts property black box?

    Because you can not see what the microcode blob does with your CPU? The CPU you can not inspect also? Or the GPU? Or the BIOS?